When buyers evaluate a large farmland acquisition, they spend countless hours reviewing yield history, cash rent, crop rotations, drainage, grain storage, equipment, leases, financing, and market outlook.
All of those factors matter.
But one of the most valuable assets on the property often receives little or no attention.
The existing fertility is already in the soil.
Whether you’re purchasing 160 acres or 34,000 acres, the nutrients that have accumulated over decades of fertilizer applications may represent a significant tax opportunity when properly evaluated under Internal Revenue Code Section 180.
For many buyers, this is one of the last pieces of due diligence considered, if it is considered at all.
The Soil Already Has Value
When farmland changes hands, buyers aren’t just purchasing dirt.
They’re purchasing an agricultural asset that may already contain valuable reserves of phosphorus, potassium, and other plant nutrients applied by previous owners.
Those nutrients required real dollars to purchase.
In certain situations, a portion of that existing fertility may qualify for a current tax deduction under IRC Section 180 when supported by proper agronomic analysis and documentation.
The result can be substantial.
On large acquisitions, even modest excess fertility values can translate into meaningful tax deductions.
While every property is different, properly identifying and documenting existing fertility can significantly improve the after-tax economics of a farmland purchase.
Above-Ground Improvements Get the Attention
When a farm is listed for sale, marketing materials naturally focus on visible improvements:
- Grain storage
- Equipment buildings
- Farm shops
- Homes
- Road access
- Irrigation
- Tenant quality
- Crop history
These are all important.
However, some of the most valuable assets cannot be seen from the road.
The soil itself may contain years of accumulated nutrient investments that deserve the same level of due diligence as any building or infrastructure improvement.
Timing Matters
One of the most common mistakes occurs immediately after closing.
Many buyers begin fertility programs before understanding the property’s existing nutrient levels.
Once new fertilizer has been applied, distinguishing between nutrients acquired with the property and nutrients added by the new owner becomes more difficult.
For that reason, timing is critical.
A soil fertility evaluation should generally be considered as part of the acquisition process and completed before significant fertility applications alter the property’s existing condition.
Planning ahead helps preserve the integrity of the analysis and strengthens the supporting documentation.
Organic and Regenerative Farms Present Unique Considerations
Many buyers assume organically managed farms have lower fertility levels.
That is not always the case.
Long-term manure applications, cover crops, compost, and carefully managed nutrient programs can produce soil fertility profiles that differ significantly from conventionally managed farms.
Each property should be evaluated based on actual soil test data rather than assumptions about its management history.
The tax analysis depends on documented nutrient levels, not whether the farm is conventional or certified organic.
Every Farm Purchase Should Include a Soil Fertility Review
A comprehensive acquisition review should consider more than productivity and cash flow.
Before closing, buyers should consider evaluating:
- Existing soil fertility levels
- Historical fertilizer management
- Recent soil test data
- Variable-rate application history
- Yield maps
- Crop rotation history
- Nutrient removal estimates
- Documentation needed to support potential IRC Section 180 deductions
These items can provide valuable insight into both the agronomic condition of the property and its potential tax treatment.
Who Benefits Most?
A soil fertility evaluation may be appropriate for:
- Farmers expanding their operations
- Family offices investing in farmland
- Institutional investors
- 1031 exchange buyers
- Agricultural investment funds
- Farm management companies
- Agricultural lenders conducting due diligence
For sophisticated buyers, understanding every component of a property’s value is simply good
business.
Looking Beyond the Purchase Price
The purchase price is only one part of the investment equation.
Understanding what you’re buying beneath the surface can materially affect your after-tax return, first-year cash flow, and long-term investment performance.
As farmland values continue to rise, buyers are becoming more sophisticated in their due diligence.
Evaluating existing soil fertility should be part of that process.
Disclaimer
This article is provided for educational purposes only and should not be considered tax, legal, or accounting advice. Eligibility for deductions under IRC Section 180 depends on the specific facts and circumstances of each transaction. Buyers should consult qualified tax advisors and experienced agricultural professionals before making tax-related decisions
Alec Bean is the CEO of Soil Tax Guys, he is a Certified Crop Advisor and has spent his entire career in Agronomic Consulting relating to soil fertility. He can be reached at [email protected] to discuss how Soil Fertility Tax Deductions fit into your land buying strategy.