Section 180 Seller Tax Consequences
Short answer: When a buyer treats part of the price as payment for fertilizer, that same slice may be ordinary income to the seller instead of capital gain on land. The IRS can compare both returns. Agreeing on the allocation in the contract — and pricing the seller’s extra tax into the deal — protects both sides.
Why the seller is involved at all
A farmland sale is really a sale of several things: land, maybe tile, fences and buildings, and — if the buyer claims it — unexhausted fertilizer. Gain on land held more than a year is usually long-term capital gain. The IRS’s Publication 225, as summarized by Iowa State’s Center for Agricultural Law and Taxation, says a farmer who sells land after deducting fertilizer or lime reports the part of the price attributable to the unused fertilizer or lime as ordinary income (CALT overview). [Attorney: confirm current Pub. 225 cite] CALT applies the same logic to a buyer’s residual fertilizer allocation: it’s a farm input the seller already deducted, leaving a zero basis (CALT). No case or ruling has applied that rule to a residual fertilizer allocation directly.
Do the two returns have to match?
- Sale of a farm business (land plus equipment, inventory, the operation): both parties must file Form 8594, and the allocations must match.
- Sale of land only: no Form 8594, and the law doesn’t require the allocations to match. But on audit, the IRS can look at both returns, and a buyer’s deduction with no corresponding income on the seller’s side is weak evidence.
What it costs the seller: an example
Assumptions (illustrative): $28,800 of the price is allocated to documented fertilizer. The seller’s ordinary rate is 35% (federal and state); their long-term capital gain rate is 20%.
| Allocated to land | Allocated to fertilizer | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax on the $28,800 | $5,760 | $10,080 |
| Seller’s extra tax | — | $4,320 |
Meanwhile the buyer saves about $10,080 in year one (see How much can I save?). Because the buyer’s saving is usually larger than the seller’s extra cost, there’s room to share it — for example, a price adjustment that covers the seller’s extra tax.
Situations that change the seller’s picture
| Seller | Effect |
|---|---|
| Active farmer who fertilized and deducted it | Likely ordinary income on the fertilizer slice |
| Estate or heirs selling soon after a death | Basis generally stepped up at death, so there may be little gain on any slice [Attorney: confirm treatment] |
| Cash-rent landlord whose tenant applied the fertilizer | Open question: the seller didn’t apply it, and the only IRS guidance speaks of fertilizer applied by the prior owner. Buyers should treat these deals cautiously |
| Seller unaware of the buyer’s allocation | The transaction doesn’t balance — a point the USDA webinar deck raises directly (source) |
How to handle it at the table
- Raise it early. Surprising a seller after closing damages the relationship and the evidence.
- Put the number in the contract. An agreed allocation, backed by the seller’s records, is the strongest support a buyer can have. See the sample clause in Buyer timeline.
- Share records. The seller’s application records are the buyer’s best proof. Providing them costs the seller nothing.
- Price the tax. Consider an adjustment for the seller’s extra tax, run past both parties’ advisers.
- Report consistently. Each side reports the allocation it agreed to.
Next:Buyer timeline, Audit risk and penalties, Who qualifies
Sources
- Tidgren, Iowa State CALT (seller ordinary income; Form 8594; contract allocation)
- CALT, Deducting Farm Expenses: An Overview
- Tidgren & Coutu, USDA webinar deck, July 2025

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!